Elsevier

Information Economics and Policy

The economics of gateway technologies and network evolution: Lessons from electricity supply history

Abstract

Contemporary economic issues concerning technological innovation and compatibility standardization in emergent 'network' industries are illuminated indirectly in this paper by the examination of the historical development of the technology of electric light and power systems in the United States and Europe during the late nineteenth and early twentieth century. The discussion focuses on the rivalry between the initially incompatible technical formulations of a system supplying electric lighting and power. In the dynamics of competition between alternative technologies under such conditions, the details of the timing of small historical events could have important and lasting consequences.

Special notice is given to the role which the induced invention of a compatibility-creating technical device-the rotary converter-played in the conduct and resolution of the so-called 'Battle of the Systems'. The rotary converter is analyzed as a paradigmatic 'gateway innovation', one of a large class of 'minor' technological innovations whose actual importance in the context of network evolution warrants greater recognition from economists.

References (68)

  • Duopoly compatibility standards with partial cooperation and standards leadership

    Information Economies and Policy

    (1988)
  • F.L. Alvarado et al.

    Methodology for analysis of multi-terminal HVDC systems

  • W.Brian Arthur

    Why a Silicon Valley?: The pure theory of locational choice

  • W.Brian Arthur

    Competing technologies and lock-in by historical small events: The dynamics of allocation under increasing returns

  • W.Brian Arthur et al.

    Strong laws for a class of path-dependent urn processes

  • W.S. Barstow

    Notes on the alternating current system of distribution

    AIEE Transactions

    (1901)
  • Stanley M. Besen et al.

    Compatibility standards, competition, and innovation in the broadcasting industry, Nov

    (1986)
  • T.R. Bresnahan et al.

    Strategic effects in the diffusion of innovations: Testable implication and preliminary findings for the case of automatic teller machines in U.S. banking markets

  • Gerald Brock

    Competition, standards and self-regulation in the computer industry

  • Julie A. Bunn

    Politics, markets, and engineers: A re-examination of the 'engineering backwardness' and 'engineering culture' hypotheses as explanations for lags in British electrical industry development

  • I.C.R. Byatt

    The British electrical industry, 1875–1914: The economic returns to a new technology

    (1979)
  • W.Bernard Carlson et al.

    Defining risk in a business context: Thomas A. Edison and Elihu Thomson, and the a.c.-d.c. controversy, 1885–1900

  • Dennis W. Carlton et al.

    The need for coordination among firms, with special reference to network industries

    The University of Chicago Law Review

    (1983)
  • Margaret Cheney

    Tesla: Man out of time

    (1981)
  • Michael Cusumono

    Note on VTR industry and market development: Japan, the U.S., and Europe, ca. 1975–1985

  • Paul A. David

    Technical choice, innovation and economic growth: Essays on American and British experience in the nineteenth century

    (1975)
  • Paul A. David

    Clio and the economics of QWERTY

    American Economic Review

    (1985)
  • Paul A. David

    Understanding the economics of QWERTY: The necessity of history

  • Paul A. David

    The hero and the herd in technological history: Reflections on Thomas Edison and the 'battle of the systems'

  • Paul A. David

    Some new standards for the economists of standardization in the information age

  • Paul A. David et al.

    'The battle of the systems' and the evolutionary dynamics of network technology rivalries

  • Paul A. David et al.

    The equilibrium dynamics of diffusion when incremental technological innovations are foreseen

    Ricerche Economiche

    (1986)
  • Electrical World Electrical World Electrical World Electrical World Electrical World Electrical World Electrical World Electrical World
  • G.T. Evans

    Some phases of the alternating current

    Electrical World

    (1892)
  • Joseph Farrell et al.

    Standardization, compatibility and innovation

    Rand Journal

    (1985)
  • Joseph Farrell et al.

    Economic issues in standardization

  • Joseph Farrell et al.

    Installed base and compatibility, with implications for product preannouncements

  • Joseph Farrell et al.

    Competition, compatibility, and standards: The economics of horses, penguins and lemmings

  • J.A. Fleming

    Fifty years of electricity: The memories of an electrical engineer

    (1921)
  • J.A. Fleming

    Electricity supply

    Encyclopedia Britannica

    (1910–1911)
  • J.A. Fleming

    Transformers

    Encyclopedia Britannica

    (1910–1911)
  • T. Fudenberg et al.

    Dynamic models of oligopoly

  • David Hemenway

    Industrywide voluntary product standards

    (1975)

    • Cited by (160)

    • Grand visions and pragmatic integration: Exploring the evolution of Europe's electricity regime

      2019, Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions

      This in turn enables contemporary policy debates about regime transitions to be contextualised and, crucially, the influence of historical continuities to be uncovered and explored. A key aim of socio-technical systems research has been to understand the processes through which technologies and institutions become intertwined; these typically remain hidden in contemporary policy debates, but have been shown to be highly influential in processes of electricity system change (David and Bunn, 1988, Unruh, 2000). The remainder of the paper is structured as follows: In the next section we outline our analytical approach which, as mentioned above, is based on socio-technical systems theory, and in particular the analysis of regimes for coordinating cross-border flows of electrical energy in a European context and their transitions.

    • Multi-mode standardisation: A critical review and a research agenda

      2017, Research Policy

      This implies that private actors must provide a clear policy-related rationale to persuade governments to intervene. Both cases of successful and failed attempts to involve government have been documented, for example by David (1992), David and Bunn (1988), Gao et al. (2014), and Gao (2014). Standardisation literature offers no insights into the reasons for these successes or failures, but the findings in other streams of literature may apply in this context.

    • Personal artifact ecologies in the context of mobile knowledge workers

      2017, Computers in Human Behavior

      '" One technological solution that helps workers to ameliorate these gaps and thus sustain a workable artifact ecology is gateway technologies, which resolve the so-called 'Battle of the Systems' (David & Bunn, 1988). Several participants used gateway tools to connect competing ecosystems.

    Arrow Up and Right View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text

    Copyright © 1988 Published by Elsevier B.V.